Mandatory consultation: A contest with no winners
Prepared by Hannah Neville (Director), Gyde Consulting
Community engagement exists to give people a voice in shaping places but despite the resources poured into consultation, the relationship between communities and the development industry feels increasingly adversarial. Communities feel unheard, developers are exasperated by relentless opposition, and governments are caught in the middle.
Mandatory consultation serves an important democratic purpose – ensuring communities are heard before decisions are made. But is the way we mandate it shaped more by a desire to minimise political risk than to improve planning outcomes? By concentrating our obligations late in the process, when proposals are substantially resolved, we create a system focused on demonstrating that people were consulted, rather than genuinely inviting them to help shape the outcome. Directing engagement resources to this late stage, when the focus has shifted to securing approval, incentivises procedural compliance over meaningful dialogue and quelling opposition over curious consideration. Ironically, the very approach intended to minimise political risk may be deepening community opposition and distrust, making projects increasingly difficult to progress.

When consultation becomes a contest
When we invite communities to consider a proposal which is already substantially developed and the scope to influence it is limited, we usually attract participation in the form of support or opposition. That leaves proponents and decision-makers with a binary choice in response to opposition: defend or concede.
Neither is inherently wrong; a sound proposal may deserve defending and feedback may justify substantial change, however, both are reactive responses to a proposal that has already taken shape. Defending can leave communities feeling dismissed, while conceding to quell opposition can undermine confidence in the planning process. The problem is most consequential when either is a predetermined response rather than the product of considered assessment. Whether we’re advocating for a client or assessing a proposal, our professional responsibility is to approach feedback with curiosity, test its planning merits and be prepared to challenge our own assumptions. That takes both judgement and courage.
Popularity does not equal planning merit
Community feedback is important evidence, but popularity does not equal planning merit. A heavily opposed proposal may be sound while a quiet one may be deeply flawed. Balancing housing needs, infrastructure capacity, environmental impacts, feasibility and long-term public benefit takes professional judgement rather than a tally of sentiment.
Consider a proposal to increase permissible building heights to 40 storeys across an established urban centre. Following consultation and strong opposition, the proposed limit drops to 30. Concerns about overshadowing, infrastructure or neighbourhood character may be entirely legitimate, and the reduction may be justified. But what if the only explanation offered is that the community expressed concern? Those ten storeys aren’t free. They likely represent homes that won’t be built, infrastructure investment that no longer stacks up or public benefits that become unviable. Was the trade-off assessed, or did the number move because the opposition was loud?
Sound planning judgement is critical at every scale but the stakes are particularly high when setting strategic planning policy. A concession on an individual development application may affect feasibility and outcomes for one project; a concession embedded in precinct-wide planning controls can shape development opportunities, housing capacity and infrastructure investment for decades. It also establishes the framework against which subsequent proposals will be assessed.
When responsiveness takes precedence over sound planning judgement, we risk incentivising greater volumes of opposition rather than more considered feedback. The effects can be cumulative: the more routinely concessions are made in response to opposition (especially without clear planning justification), the more communities will come to expect them and the more cynical the process becomes. What appears to minimise political risk in the short term may actually compound it, reinforcing adversarial behaviour, undermining trust in the process and making future change increasingly difficult.
How can engagement bring communities with us towards a more sustainable urban future?
Better engagement doesn’t necessarily mean more engagement. Despite working in the field, I’d argue that in some circumstances, we need less of it – but that’s another article! It’s time to reconsider where our planning systems mandate consultation, at what stage and for what purpose. Rather than adding more requirements, we should be asking whether our existing obligations direct resources towards the activities most likely to improve planning outcomes.
Rethink what we mandate
Rather than concentrating consultation obligations at the point when proposals are substantially resolved, our planning systems should recognise and give weight to earlier, meaningful engagement and the thoughtful use of existing community insights. Communities shouldn’t need to repeat themselves with every new project. Demonstrating how past feedback and early engagement have informed a proposal should count for something, potentially reducing the resources required at later stages. Retain formal notification as an important safeguard, but reconsider whether our obligations direct engagement effort to where it can deliver the greatest value.
Shift the effort upstream
Help communities see themselves in projects. For major projects, start by understanding local values, identity, everyday experiences and aspirations before a concept takes shape. Invite ideas, identify opportunities and explore concerns while there is still genuine scope to respond. Equally, use these conversations to build shared understanding of why change is needed, what it could deliver and the trade-offs involved. Use that intelligence to shape more distinctive, place-responsive proposals that balance community aspirations with development objectives, rather than waiting to defend or concede once a proposal is substantially resolved.
Exercise and explain planning judgement
Quiet the instinct to immediately refute opposition or concede to it. Approach feedback with curiosity, understand what sits behind it and test its planning merits. Change can be uncomfortable, and even sound proposals attract strong opposition. Be prepared to defend a sound proposal or recommend meaningful change, but let planning merit rather than the volume of opposition determine the response. The broader the consequences of a decision, the greater the responsibility to exercise that judgement with confidence and transparently explain the trade-offs.
Beyond the contest
Planning will always involve competing interests, and consensus shouldn’t be the measure of successful engagement. Communities deserve to be genuinely understood, developers deserve a process grounded in planning merit, and assessing authorities need the confidence to make and defend difficult decisions.
We won’t rebuild trust by giving communities more opportunities to object, or by making concessions simply to quieten opposition. We need to direct engagement effort towards shaping proposals rather than defending them, make better use of what communities have already told us and restore sound planning judgement to the centre of decision-making.
The real test isn’t how little opposition remains. It’s whether we’ve understood the community, improved the planning outcome and made a decision we can comfortably justify.